This Doctor Nailed The Problem With Diagnosing Donald Trump With Mental Illness
Photo: Pete Marovich/Pool/Getty Images.
Even
just a cursory glance over social media can tell you that a lot of
people think Donald Trump is "crazy," or "insane," or even an actual
narcissist. But Allen Frances, MD, who wrote the diagnostic criteria for narcissism, thinks that we shouldn't be so quick to point to mental illness when it comes to Trump.
In response to a New York Daily News article on Trump's possible narcissistic personality disorder that has been making the rounds on Twitter, Dr. Frances weighed in, saying that to speculate about Trump's mental health is to entirely miss the point.
Dr. Frances responded to another Twitter user who asked for his thoughts on the matter, tweeting that "constantly saying Trump's crazy [is] wrong & misses point."
"He doesn't meet DSM Narcisssistic criteria (I wrote them)," he wrote. "Its [sic] worse - he's bad, not mad."
In response to a New York Daily News article on Trump's possible narcissistic personality disorder that has been making the rounds on Twitter, Dr. Frances weighed in, saying that to speculate about Trump's mental health is to entirely miss the point.
Dr. Frances responded to another Twitter user who asked for his thoughts on the matter, tweeting that "constantly saying Trump's crazy [is] wrong & misses point."
"He doesn't meet DSM Narcisssistic criteria (I wrote them)," he wrote. "Its [sic] worse - he's bad, not mad."
Constantly saying Trump's crazy wrong & misses point.— Allen Frances (@AllenFrancesMD) January 30, 2017
He doesn't meet DSM Narcisssistic criteria(I wrote them).
Its worse-he's bad,not mad. https://t.co/izsw4Yy6Vu
Advertisement
Instead
of trying to diagnose Trump with mental illness, he continued, it's far
more useful (if you don't agree with his politics) to examine the
system that put him into power.
Instead of misdiagnosing Trump, we must analyze the societal sickness that gave someone so flawed the power to determine fate of the world. https://t.co/e1bepCIWd5— Allen Frances (@AllenFrancesMD) January 30, 2017
Furthermore, Dr. Frances thinks that in speculating about Trump's mental health, we are doing a disservice to those who do
suffer from mental illness. In a series of tweets, he explained why he
doesn't think Trump is a narcissist — and how harmful it can be for us
to keep assuming that he is.
DSM Narcisssistic Personality Disorder requires distress/impairment:— Allen Frances (@AllenFrancesMD) January 30, 2017
1) Trump causes, doesnt feel, distress
2) Is rewarded for being a jerk https://t.co/EJFFsN3OPk
Calling Trump crazy also insults people who suffer from mental illness, most of whom are well meaning & well mannered.— Allen Frances (@AllenFrancesMD) January 30, 2017
Trump is neither.
Advertisement
We shouldn't medicalize as mental disorder every behavior that is stupid, mean, destructive, selfish, cruel, shortsighted & self destructive https://t.co/3Apmzj7m0N— Allen Frances (@AllenFrancesMD) January 30, 2017
Diagnosing Trump mentally ill at a distance is medicalizing what should be a strong critique of this very flawed man & his terrible policies https://t.co/UOSpt7CoQ6— Allen Frances (@AllenFrancesMD) January 30, 2017
As Dr. Frances put it in a Psychology Today article published Tuesday, focusing on Trump's mental health is "well-meaning, but misguided."
"Dismissing Trump as simply mad paradoxically reduces our ability to deal with his actions," he wrote.
So while we may be tempted to look for an answer to what we see as abnormal behavior, Dr. Frances makes the great point that doing so can add further stigma to mental illness, as well as prove to be fruitless in helping us reckon with the president's actions. Sure, calling him "crazy" has become the go-to, but it may prove to do more harm than we think.
"Dismissing Trump as simply mad paradoxically reduces our ability to deal with his actions," he wrote.
So while we may be tempted to look for an answer to what we see as abnormal behavior, Dr. Frances makes the great point that doing so can add further stigma to mental illness, as well as prove to be fruitless in helping us reckon with the president's actions. Sure, calling him "crazy" has become the go-to, but it may prove to do more harm than we think.
No comments:
Post a Comment